Sag Harbor, NY Listings Dining Shopping Leisure Highest Rated Shopping Ava’s & Around Again $ 8 reviews Used, Vintage & Consignment, Women's Clothing, Accessories (631) 725-4067 1 Long Wharf StSag Harbor, NY 11963 Sylvester & Company Modern General $$ 15 reviews Coffee & Tea, Furniture Stores, Fashion (631) 725-5012 103 Main StSag Harbor, NY 11963 Sage And Madison $ 3 reviews Coffee & Tea, Gift Shops, Tabletop Games (631) 530-0977 31 Madison StSag Harbor, NY 11963 Urban Zen $ 1 reviews Women's Clothing, Accessories (631) 725-6176 16 Main StSag Harbor, NY 11963 Hudson Grace $ 1 reviews Home Decor, Gift Shops, Candle Stores (518) 880-9700 17 Washington StSag Harbor, NY 11963 Flashbacks $$ 7 reviews Women's Clothing, Accessories (631) 808-3055 69 Main StSte B Bridgehampton Commons image/svg+xml $$$ 1 reviews Shopping Centers 2044 Montauk HwyBridgehampton, NY 11932 The Exchange Thrift Shop $ 2 reviews Thrift Stores, Used, Vintage & Consignment, Community Service/Non-Profit 2350 Montauk HwyBridgehampton, NY 11932 MONC XIII $$$ 6 reviews Furniture Stores, Home Decor (631) 808-3333 40 Madison StSag Harbor, NY 11963 Black Swan Antiques $$$$ 4 reviews Antiques, Furniture Stores (631) 377-3012 26 Main StSag Harbor, NY 11963 Kites of the Harbor $$ 8 reviews Toy Stores (631) 725-9063 75 Main StSag Harbor, NY 11963 Sag Harbor Books $ 3 reviews Bookstores (631) 725-8425 7 Main StSag Harbor, NY 11963 Lifestyle $$$ 7 reviews Accessories, Women's Clothing (631) 725-1667 127 Main StSag Harbor, NY 11963 Matta $ 1 reviews Accessories, Women's Clothing (631) 899-4219 82 Main StSag Harbor, NY 11963 Satori $$ 5 reviews Women's Clothing, Accessories, Shoe Stores (631) 899-3784 2442 Montauk HwyBridgehampton, NY 11932 Schiavoni's Market $$ 26 reviews Grocery (631) 725-0366 48 Main StSag Harbor, NY 11963 D J Hart $$$ 5 reviews Women's Clothing, Jewelry, Accessories (631) 725-5849 34 Main StSag Harbor, NY 11963 Marika's $ 3 reviews Antiques, Furniture Stores, Home Decor (401) 862-6607 6 S Ferry RdShelter Island, NY 11964 Provisions $$ 47 reviews Health Markets, Grocery (631) 725-3636 7 Main StSag Harbor, NY 11963 Faherty Sag Harbor $ 1 reviews Men's Clothing, Women's Clothing (631) 725-1030 56 Main StSag Harbor, NY 11963 The Retreat Boutique Thrift Store image/svg+xml $$ 4 reviews Thrift Stores (631) 537-3845 6 Spc Store 110 Bridgehampton CommonsBridgehampton, NY 11932 Marie Eiffel $$$$ 4 reviews Fashion (631) 749-0707 8 Grand AveShelter Island, NY 11964 Canio's Books $$ 8 reviews Bookstores, Art Galleries (631) 725-4926 290 Main StSag Harbor, NY 11963 Black Cat Books $$ 6 reviews Used Bookstore (631) 725-8654 54 N Ferry RdShelter Island, NY 11964